in a hat but not without a hat. Moreover, the NPC john's hairstyle from 2 john is the same hairstyle from 1 part, only a little longer and not combed, and this is a fact. take another look at the mb gif?
Where does the longer NPC hair not fit John for his Part 1 look? if he has long hair in 1 part. in 2 parts of the rdr he has a couple of centimeters longer hair and they are not tucked back as in 1 part